Originally, the Club was composed of men, mostly of German, Scottish, English, Irish, and other Anglo-Saxon extraction, but throughout the years, the composition of the Club changed. French and Italian surnames started to appear in the roster. The wider membership continued to expand. In 1989 the board of directors of Rotary International asked clubs to accept women. It did not take too long for a woman to be invited into our Club. She was Nancy Battersby, who joined the club in 1990. Nancy also became the first female president, when she served in 1998-99. Irene Kalnins became the Club's first Latvian-born Rotarian in 1994. Also during this decade, George Wang became the first Asian to join the Club; he was born in China.

The 1990's also saw the Club presided by its first Hispanic president; Guillo Rodríguez, a native of Puerto Rico, joined the club in 1995 and became its president in 1999-2000. At the start of the 2002-03 Rotary year and under the presidency of Luis Ortiz, the Club welcomed its first African-Americans to its ranks. They were Lee Moss and Ed Robinson.

The Club has also distinct representation of some of the world's religions. The Club members profess many creeds, including Christianity (Protestants, Catholics, etc.), and Judaism, among others. All members respect each other and believe that the diversity in the Club is an asset upon which to build good relationships that translate into good deeds for humanity.